Spring 2022
- Hannah Brown, Cheer – UT Southern
- Joe Cummings, Football – Birmingham Southern College
- Julia Halterman, Cross Country – Lee University
- Amanda Hambly, Cheer – Western Kentucky University
- Sam Henke, Football – University of Toronto
- Brady Jenkins, Football – Lindsey Wilson College
- Jack Rummel, Football – Tennessee Tech
- Luke Tedder, Soccer – Trevecca Nazarene University
Fall 2021
- Piper Davis, Golf – Lipscomb University
- Cooper Hargrove, Baseball – Trevecca Nazarene University
- Logan Molnar, Baseball – Austin Peay State University
- Jessica Perry, Volleyball – University of Connecticut
- Hannah Jaywook, Swimming – University of Connecticut
- Ruby Teixeira, Soccer – West Virginia University
2020-2021
- Cooper Allan, Football – Army
- Jacob Almon, Baseball – Bryan College
- Morgan Brown, Softball – Albany State University
- Luke Byrum, Track & Field – Middle Tennessee State University
- Zach Byrum, Track & Field – Middle Tennessee State University
- Jaxson Campbell, Football – Navy
- Andrew Holloway, Football – Sewanee
- Emily Jones, Cheer – Butler University
- Olivia Shearer, Softball – Union College
- Will Tobin, Baseball – University of Pennsylvania
- MaKinlee Webb, Softball – University of North Alabama
2019-2020
- Chayce Bishop, Football – University of Tennessee
- Josie Bond, Softball
- Ethan Cash, Football – Lindsey Wilson College
- Sydney Hammond, Soccer – University of Texas, Rio Grande Valley
- Robert Hassell, Baseball – Vanderbilt University, #8 MLB Draft by San Diego Padres
- Isa Huner, Track & Field – Liberty University
- Malania Miles, Volleyball
- Rachel Picha, Volleyball
- Chase Robertson, Football – Princeton University
- Slater Schield, Baseball – Rhodes College
- Lauren Spaanstra, Soccer – Middle Tennessee State University
- Calvin Wilson, Football – University of Mississippi
2018-2019
- Hunter Bossman, Soccer – Lipscomb University
- Montana Dickerson, Baseball – Roane State Community College
- Chayton Gray, Baseball – Rhodes College
- Katelyn Huckaby, Softball – Walters State Community College
- Jake Huner, Football – Tennessee Tech University
- Kelsey Leedle, Basketball – Queens College
- Daesha McAdams, Basketball – Oglethorpe College
- Josie McReynolds, Soccer – Millsaps College
- Tracy Roy, Soccer – Trevecca Nazarene University
- Tyler Roy, Soccer – Trevecca Nazarene University
- Grace Sanchez, Soccer – Martin Methodist College
- TJ Sheffield, Football – Purdue University
2017-2018
- Selena Barnett, Track & Field – University of the Cumberlands
- Gentry Davis, Soccer – Belmont University
- Beau Escobar, Baseball – Walter State Community College
- Caleb Green, Baseball – Freed-Hardeman University
- Kyle Greenwell, Football – University of Alabama Birmingham
- Troy Henderson, Football – Liberty University
- Andrew Hendry, Track & Field – Lee University
- Hannah Johnson, Track & Field – Murray State University
- Zion Katina, Football – Kennesaw State University
- Beau Meyers, Football – Samford University
- Dillan Saunders, Baseball – Lindsey Wilson College
- Zanaya Shropshire, Wrestling – MacMurray College
- Shawn Wallwork, Baseball – Tevecca Nazarene University
2016-2017
- Jake Brickell, Football – Liberty University
- Julie Garst, Soccer – Belmont University
- Landon Guidry, Football – Mississippi State University
- Ellen Hicks, Basketball – Centre College
- Brandon Hines, Football – University of Tennessee
- Cole Huner, Football – Tennessee Tech University
- Grayson Murphy, Basketball – Belmont Unversity
2015-2016
- Chris Beavers, Football – Bethel University
- Andrew Bunch, Football – University of Nebraska
- Samantha Colley, Soccer – Rice University
- Tyler Delgado, Soccer – Trevecca Nazarene University
- Peter Dorsten, Football – Samford University
- Dillan Friesner, Wrestling – University of Illinois
- Keegan Hudson, Football – Alcorn State University
- Seth Huner, Football – Tennessee Tech University
- Nate Johnson, Football – University of Michigan
- Taylor Johnson, Softball – Tusculum University
- Patrick Murphy, Basketball – Martin Methodist College
- Thomas Newberg, Football – Tennessee State University
- Kevin Pierce, Soccer – Trevecca Nazarene University
- Kylan Stribling, Football – Middle Tennessee State University
- Adam Swayze, Football – Tennessee Tech University
- Malcolm Walker, Basketball – Maryville College
- Pierre Watkins, Basketball – Maryville College
2014-2015
- Dom Childress, Track & Field – Navy
- Austin Osborne, Basketball – Cincinnati Christian University
- Ashley Weathers, Soccer – Miami University
- Malik Webster, Football – University of Dayton
2013-2014
- Jarret Crof, Golf – Texas Southern University
- Rashaun Gaulden, Football – University of Tennessee
- Elizabeth Kroeger, Cross Country – North Carolina State University
- Lucas Luttrell, Basketball – Faulkner University
- Caleb Miller, Basketball – Lipscomb University
- Trent Perry, Basketball – Eastern Michigan University
- Stephen Satchel, Football – Navy
- Finis Stribling, Football – University of Missouri
- Vic Wharton, Football – University of Tennessee
2012-2013
- Drew Kelley, Football – Murray State University
- Jessica Twaddle, Softball – Murray State University
- Jalen Wade, Football – Navy
- Henry Reterdorf, Football – Centre College
2011-2012
- Landon Foster, Football – University of Kentucky
- Kris Howard, Cross Country – Belmont University
- Brianna McCombs, Volleyball – Lipscomb University
- McCoy Newberg, Wrestling – University of Nebraska
- Brandon Swayze, Football – Gardner-Webb University
2010-2011
- Caroline Carlton, Volleyball – Mercer University
- Brennen Cox, Wrestling – University of Tennessee
- Rycine Ellison, Jr., Track & Field – Middle Tennessee State University
- Brian Miller, Baseball – Vanderbilt University
2009-2010
- Mariah Davis, Soccer – Union University
- Nicholas Dykes, Soccer – East Tennessee State University
- Joshua Lee, Baseball – Vanderbilt University
- Ty Stannard, Football – University of Tennessee Chattanooga
2008-2009
- Matt Atkins, Football – Carthage College
- Dalton Burge, Football – Cumberland University
- Ali Eisnaugle, Soccer – Lee University
- Joshua Helton, Cross Country – Belmont University
- Katherine Kroeger, Cross Country – Stanford University
- Samantha Serley, Volleyball – University of Alabama Birmingham
- Terone Shephard, Football – Harding University
- Nate Stout, Football – Campbellsville University
- Lauren Stratton, Golf – Vanderbilt University
2007-2008
- Isaac Von Baugh, Football – University of Buffal0
- Ryan Consiglio, Football – University of Tennessee Chattanooga
- Seth Obermyer, Soccer – Cumberland
- Scott Pettigrew, Football – University of Buffalo
- Jason Veres, Football – University of Tennessee Chattanooga
2006-2007
- Moses Sixtos, Soccer – University of Tennessee Chattanooga
